Post-Bankruptcy Options for Underwater Second Mortgages

It’s not possible for debtors to cram down or reduce the principal amount of a primary mortgage in a New York bankruptcy case. This was an unfortunate route that Congress chose to take during the Great Recession. Although, debtors do have options for dealing with junior mortgages that are underwater, i.e. not secured by any equity after the senior mortgage is accounted for. Often, debtors discharge them in a chapter 7 case, which eliminates their personal liabilities on the debts, but this leaves the liens the creditors still have on their homes—along with substantial monthly payments. What options do debtors have for second mortgages that are underwater?

The answer is quite a few.

(1)  Commit to a chapter 13 bankruptcy to strip the second lien from the home. I’ve discussed this option frequently. New York bankruptcy lawyers call this the “chapter 20” option, i.e. it’s a chapter 13 bankruptcy filed after a successful chapter 7 case, adding up to twenty. The advantage here is that after all their unsecured debts have been discharged, they shouldn’t have as much difficultly completing the repayment plan. On the other hand, it does require a three-to-five-year commitment.

(2)  Negotiate with the lender to reduce the value of the lien. This might be a surprising option. Why would lenders be willing to negotiate when they can always foreclose? The answer is that in many cases it’s not worth their while to bother for a variety of reasons. Foreclosures cost them in legal fees, they don’t want the home, and they have to satisfy the senior mortgage creditor, which is also underwater, to purchase the home. In other words, the full amount of the second mortgage is not actually what you’re negotiating over. Often debtors can promise to pay as little as ten percent of the second mortgage in a lump sum to release the creditor’s lien on their homes. This can be a lot less than the amount they’d pay under a chapter 13 plan.

(3)  Do nothing. This is an even more surprising option, and to the extent it is an option and available to debtors, it’s only because they don’t have the money to settle with their creditors. It’s likely to work only if the junior mortgage is so hopelessly underwater that the creditor won’t gain anything by foreclosing. The lien will remain until the debtors either settle or refinance the home.

(4)  Refinance. Debtors can try to split the difference between doing nothing and negotiating for a lump-sum payoff if they can convince the junior creditor to refinance the home, reducing the total amount to be paid and consequently the monthly payments.

Of course, debtors can always choose to just sell the home, particularly if they’ve already discharged the second mortgage, but that leaves them with a deficiency for the first mortgage, which they aren’t going to be able to discharge for several years. As a result, consulting with an experienced New York bankruptcy lawyer before filing any bankruptcy is the best option for resolving an underwater junior mortgage.

For answers to more questions about bankruptcy, the automatic stay, effective strategies for dealing with foreclosure, and protecting your assets in bankruptcy please feel free to contact experienced bankruptcy  lawyer Brooklyn NY Bruce Weiner for a free initial consultation.

Rosenberg, Musso & Weiner, L.L.P
26 Court St # 2211
Brooklyn, NY 11242, USA

Recent Posts

Preference actions: The art of making them disappear

I had a client situation recently that reminded me of how important preparation and know-how are when dealing with preference actions. The client had received a demand letter from a debtor in a Chapter 11 case (who has the powers of a trustee) informing him that he would be subject to a preference lawsuit unless

Read More »

Bruce Weiner Debtor Case Studies: Other people’s debts

“Bruce Weiner Debt Case Studies” is a recurring feature on this blog that summarizes some of the facts in a client’s bankruptcy case.  The goal is to share the kinds of real world circumstances that lead people to bankruptcy, and to demonstrate how the bankruptcy process and a good bankruptcy lawyer can help. Case Study: 

Read More »

Should I file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy?

How do you know if you should file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, rather than say Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy? I’ve worked for over 30 years as a bankruptcy lawyer in New York, and while Chapter 7 bankruptcy (aka liquidation) is by far the most common, and Chapter 13 bankruptcy (aka repayment plan) is

Read More »

Can my employer fire me for filing for bankruptcy?

Can my employer fire me for filing for bankruptcy?  Can my employer fire me based on my race? No and no.  You can’t be fired based on your race.  And you can’t be fired just because you’ve filed for bankruptcy.  The bankruptcy laws specifically prohibit firing an employee because of a bankruptcy filing. Many people

Read More »

How much will a bankruptcy filing affect my FICO score?

How much does a bankruptcy filing affect your FICO score?  In the big picture, this may not be the right question to ask. In 2010 FICO made public some–not all, just some–of the information behind their mysterious, black-box credit scoring system. The answer to the bankruptcy question is:  It depends on the individual.  But it appears

Read More »

How does debt and bankruptcy affect senior citizens?

Elderly Americans are frequently victims of debt problems and need to file bankruptcy.  Especially those on fixed incomes.  However, many senior citizens don’t realize that they also have certain advantages afforded to them under the bankruptcy laws. For example, retirement accounts and social security income are almost always protected from creditors. And many senior citizens

Read More »