Free Consultation
The office is open as per the NYS Covid-19 guidelines. We are now doing both in-person and telephone consultations. Please call the office at 718-855-6840 to schedule a time to speak with one of our experienced bankruptcy attorneys.

Attorney-Client Privilege: Whose Is It in an Individual New York Bankruptcy?

The short answer is: We don’t know—according to a November 2016 article in New York Law Journal. In discussing the topic, the authors could not find any court cases in the Second Circuit addressing which party controls the attorney-client privilege in a New York bankruptcy.

Before explaining why this is an issue, it’s necessary to clarify what the attorney-client privilege (“ACP”, or “the privilege”) is.

Most people are aware that lawyers must keep any information their clients give them in confidence, and no court, legislature, or other public entity can compel their lawyers to disclose it. ACP is one of the most important benefits lawyers provide their clients, and state law even requires it. Lawyers’ subordinates, like paralegals or assistants, are also bound by ACP. Thus, individual debtors might be surprised to learn that a New York bankruptcy lawyer might not be able to serve them as other lawyers would (or at least that the issue is obscure). So why is there a problem?

Partly it emerges from how bankruptcy treats ACP when the debtor is a corporate entity. A 1985 U.S. Supreme Court case, Commodity Futures Trading Commission v. Weintraub, held that the trustee holds the privilege—that is, the trustee is the party that can waive the privilege and disclose information the debtor told its bankruptcy lawyer. (The trustee here can be the debtor-in-possession in a chapter 11 case.) This may seem peculiar, but the trustee is responsible for managing the debtor’s assets, even if he or she is not a private fiduciary agent of the debtor. The Court emphasized that the ruling in Weintraub only applied to corporate entities and not individual debtors, and it hasn’t heard a case on that issue, so the circuit courts of appeal have decided for themselves.

Some circuits have extended the Court’s reasoning in Weintraub to individual debtors: Bankruptcy trustees manage individual debtors’ assets, so they hold the privilege. Other circuits have taken the opposite position, reasoning that individual debtors expect more privacy in their personal affairs than a corporation does, and they believe they are entitled to the same ACP that other clients receive. Finally some courts are trying to find a balance between the two poles.

Thankfully, the reason the question of who holds the privilege in an individual bankruptcy has not come up is that so little of what debtors tell their lawyers ultimately falls within the scope of the privilege. Nearly everything important that debtors tell their bankruptcy lawyers will be publicly disclosed in bankruptcy filings anyway. Discussions of strategy, while protected by ACP, aren’t going to be challenged by a party because they aren’t relevant. Moreover, if the bankruptcy strategy includes fraudulent activities, ACP wouldn’t apply anyway.

The New York Law Journal article is here.

Debtors should know that state law does protect their communications with their clients, and nothing in the Bankruptcy Code or court rulings changes that. However, they should also be aware that very little of what they communicate with their lawyers actually needs such protection. There might be some exceptions, like debtors whose bankruptcy lawyers also handle their civil litigation matters, but again those situations have not come up. If you are encountering financial difficulties, don’t let concerns about attorney-client privilege trip you up from consulting with an experienced New York bankruptcy lawyer.

For answers to more questions about bankruptcy, the automatic stay, effective strategies for dealing with foreclosure, and protecting your assets in bankruptcy please feel free to contact experienced Brooklyn bankruptcy attorney Bruce Weiner for a free initial consultation.

Rosenberg, Musso & Weiner, L.L.P
26 Court St # 2211
Brooklyn, NY 11242, USA
718-855-6840
http://nybankruptcy.net/

Recent Posts

Beware Grace Periods, Debtors

Too often, debtors see grace periods offered by lenders as free benefits. “Grace” makes it sound so innocent. However, debtors who routinely rely on grace periods when making payments will find themselves facing financial difficulties that might lead to bankruptcy. The reason is that although creditors offer grace periods to debtors, they also use them

Read More »

Bankruptcy May Not Rescue You From Vicious Personal Disputes

Bankruptcy is a technical process that assumes everyone working within it is mostly rational. To the extent that it expects parties to deviate from irrational behavior, the Bankruptcy Code and its accompanying rules include incentives to keep parties in line. Creditors are usually large and impersonal, and they rarely care if their debtors file bankruptcy.

Read More »

Non-Lawyers’ Explanations of Bankruptcy May Be Wrong

Do you have financial problems? Do you tend to ask your friends for advice? Is one of your friends an experienced New York bankruptcy lawyer who will explain the process for you? Are your friends otherwise knowledgeable people? The answer to these questions may be, “Yes but you don’t know it.” Although many bankruptcy lawyers

Read More »

6 Steps to Take Before Filing Bankruptcy

Leaving your case to an experienced New York bankruptcy lawyer is not the only step on the to-do list before filing bankruptcy. There are many things debtors should do (and not do) before they file, and the more organized and mindful debtors are, the easier the process will be and the more effective the result.

Read More »

Social Security Number Not Necessary for Bankruptcy

A question that’s commonly asked about New York bankruptcy is whether a debtor needs a Social Security number to file. Debtors ask because they sometimes run across the bankruptcy form title, “Your Statement About Your Social Security Numbers” (B 121), which asks debtors to list their current and prior Social Security numbers. The new bankruptcy

Read More »

How Can a Debtor (or Creditor) Get a New Trustee?

The trustee in a New York bankruptcy case is usually not the debtor’s ally. His or her purpose is mainly to administer the bankruptcy estate or ensure the debtor’s repayment plan goes according to plan. Trustees pursue preference payments, fraudulent conveyances, and other malfeasance committed by debtors. They frequently initiate adversary proceedings against debtors. In

Read More »
Scroll to Top